Two Old Souls

Two Old Souls Home Furnishings. Vintage Furniture. Custom Painted Furniture. Photo-shop Services. Vintage Treasures. The rest is history.

What We Do -
Our greatest honor is when clients ask us to paint a family heirloom or a piece they found in it's "ugly" state but knew we could make it perfect for their space. Some pieces we've painted were already gorgeous, but just the wrong style for their home or personal taste. Our job with all custom pieces is to make your vision a reality. What a thrill when a custom client or buyer of one

of our unique pieces come to pick up their furniture and they're giddy with excitement. It makes all the work, sweat and yes, sometimes blood (because we are clumsy and committed to our craft), so worth it. Who We Are -
Two Old Souls is owned by Michelle Bell and Virginia Aiello. We are friends who share a love for all things old, dusty, rusty and unique. We bonded over our love for "paint therapy,"

When naming our business, we went through several unsuccessful ideas. When Virginia thought of the name Two Old Souls, she knew that was the winner and immediately secured the Etsy page before even floating it by Michelle. Michelle LOVED the name and remarked that she had always been called an old soul. Virginia had had the same experience, which is why it came to mind. What made you choose to refinish furniture? We both find it therapeutic to take a piece of furniture that is dated, ugly, or just the wrong style, and transform it into something people are proud to have in their homes. We do the same in our own homes, but it's socially unacceptable to have 12 dressers of every color of the rainbow in a single home, so- we offer them up for sale.

This beauty is officially SOLD and heading to New York! ✨There’s something especially fun about watching a one-of-a-kind...
08/28/2026

This beauty is officially SOLD and heading to New York! ✨

There’s something especially fun about watching a one-of-a-kind antique piece find its next home. This gorgeous brass footstool is packed up and ready for its next chapter in NY.

From North Carolina to New York — off she goes! 🤎

Two Old Souls — soulful goods for a storybook home.

08/25/2026

Visit JoCo, NC visited Collected Treasures!

Such a fun surprise to spot a few glimpses of our booth in this beautiful Visit JoCo feature! 💛 So grateful to the Johnston County Visitors Bureau for highlighting Collected Treasures and some of the wonderful thrifting and vintage shopping we have right here in Johnston County. Thank you for including us in the adventure!

If you haven’t spent a day treasure hunting around JoCo, add it to your list!

A few new treasures just landed in the booth. 🍂Vintage New York World’s Fair silhouette portraits, fall-themed dictionar...
08/23/2026

A few new treasures just landed in the booth. 🍂

Vintage New York World’s Fair silhouette portraits, fall-themed dictionary prints, and vintage Madame Alexander dolls are all in now.

Come browse the newest finds at Two Old Souls.

Soulful good for a storybook home.

Fall is starting to sneak into Two Old Souls 🍂🍎🌻A little apple harvest moment with oversized sunflowers, vintage wooden ...
08/14/2026

Fall is starting to sneak into Two Old Souls 🍂🍎🌻

A little apple harvest moment with oversized sunflowers, vintage wooden apples, a rustic bowl, pumpkin basket, and plenty of warm autumn texture.

I’m trying something new this season—fewer pieces, a little more breathing room, and letting each treasure have its moment.

Come see what’s new at Two Old Souls inside Collected Treasures. 🤎

✨ A little bit of vintage magic just landed at Two Old Souls! ✨This whimsical unicorn pair is almost too sweet — creamy ...
08/10/2026

✨ A little bit of vintage magic just landed at Two Old Souls! ✨

This whimsical unicorn pair is almost too sweet — creamy white porcelain, golden horns, delicate pink ribbons, and the prettiest little floral details. 🦄🌸

One is prancing proudly while the other is resting peacefully, and together they make the most charming pair. Perfect tucked into a vintage vanity display, a little girl’s room, or anywhere that could use a touch of storybook sweetness.

Available now at Two Old Souls inside Collected Treasures. 💕
Sold as a pair — because really, how could we possibly separate them?

Not an optical illusion… and definitely not bad camera angles. 👀This incredible trapezoid mirror is actually shaped just...
08/03/2026

Not an optical illusion… and definitely not bad camera angles. 👀

This incredible trapezoid mirror is actually shaped just like that! The angled frame creates such a fun visual effect, making you stop and take a second look every time.

One of my favorite finds has already found its new home and will soon be making its way to Florida. Thank you to the wonderful customer who gave this unique piece its next chapter!

I love finding the unusual, the unexpected, and the pieces that make people say, “Wait… what am I looking at?” That’s exactly what Two Old Souls is all about.

Missed this one? Don’t worry… there’s always another treasure waiting.

North Carolina is slowly settling into the booth. ❤️I’ve started creating a little shelf celebrating our beautiful state...
08/02/2026

North Carolina is slowly settling into the booth. ❤️

I’ve started creating a little shelf celebrating our beautiful state with vintage books, local history, birds, the Outer Banks, the Executive Mansion, handmade pieces, and treasures that tell a story. There are even a few signed North Carolina authors tucked in!

This is just the beginning. I still have more to bring in, so if you love North Carolina history, vintage books, coastal treasures, or unique local finds, keep checking back.

Every visit to the booth is a little different, and I can’t wait to finish this cozy corner.

Two Old Souls
Collected Treasures, Garner, NC

Hosted by Collected Treasures!!! Awesome finds!
07/24/2026

Hosted by Collected Treasures!!! Awesome finds!

🐇 A little corner of whimsy has hopped into Two Old Souls!Our curious rabbit lamp is keeping watch over a collection of ...
07/20/2026

🐇 A little corner of whimsy has hopped into Two Old Souls!

Our curious rabbit lamp is keeping watch over a collection of fun little finds:
✨ Sparkly fish bait 🖊️ Glitter pens
🍺 Tiny vintage Anheuser-Busch Budweiser kegs
🍄 Colorful decorative mushrooms
…and who knows what else you might discover.

The rabbit lamp is available now for $39.99, and the rest of these little treasures are ready to find new homes, too.

Sometimes it’s the smallest, quirkiest finds that make people smile. Stop by Collected Treasures and see what catches your eye!

Two Old Souls – So Good for Storybook Home.

07/16/2026

Address

Garner, NC

Opening Hours

Monday 10am - 6pm
Tuesday 10am - 6pm
Wednesday 10am - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 10am - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 6pm
Sunday 12pm - 5pm

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Two Old Souls posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Two Old Souls:

Shortcuts

Share