https://www.facebook.com/506490292549487/

Firefly Cookie Co

Home
United States
Wauwatosa, WI
Firefly Cookie Co

Perry Hicks

📍Wauwatosa, WI | Milwaukee Area

Message me with any cookie requests

06/11/2026

Something blue before "I do." 🩵✨

Celebrating the bride-to-be with cookies and all the love before the big day

06/04/2026

🚨 Sound the Alarm... I'm ONE! 🚨
This little firefighter is turning one and ready to spark some birthday fun! ❤️🚒 From fire trucks to flashing lights, these cookies were the perfect way to celebrate a blazing first birthday.

05/28/2026

A little taste of where their next adventure begins ✈️🤍 These bridal shower cookies were inspired by the beautiful places the newlyweds will be traveling to after saying “I do” — from the Swiss mountains to Italy and France 💍🏔️🇮🇹🇫🇷

05/19/2026

Game day just got a little sweeter ⚽️ ❤️Custom cookies for the Wauwatosa East High School soccer team! Perfect for senior nights, team dinners, tournaments, and end-of-season celebrations, or just because!

05/08/2026

Grad season is here 🎓✨ Let cookies be one thing you can check off your list this summer!

Graduation orders are filling up fast — I’m currently booked through mid-June, but I’m now accepting orders for dates after the second week of June. Message me to get your celebration on the calendar! 🍪🎉 here are some inspo pictures of cookies I did last year!

05/02/2026

Sweet treats are arriving just in time for Mother’s Day! 💐 Stop by Look for Less this weekend to grab the perfect cookie gift for all the amazing moms, because every mom deserves something as sweet as she is!!

04/27/2026

Sweet little treats for a sweet little arrival 🍼

Celebrating a baby on the way with these custom cookies made with love and a perfect touch of sweetness for such a special day.

04/17/2026

Hello everyone! I wanted to take a moment to introduce myself to everyone! My name is Perry (Smith) Hicks, and I’m the baker behind Firefly Cookie Co. I grew up in the East Tosa neighborhood, which is exactly why I chose to name my business after the place that shaped me. “Firefly” is inspired by the meaning of Wauwatosa—something that always felt close to home.

Baking has been a love of mine since I was a kid. What started as something fun quickly became a passion I couldn’t ignore. Today, I’m a full-time teacher, and baking has grown from a hobby into something so much more.

I officially started this business in October 2024, and it has been amazing to see how much it has grown since then. I’m so grateful for the support. Thank you for being here and supporting my small business! Please reach out with any cookie requests, I’d love to help make your event even sweeter with custom cookies designed just for you! 🍪✨

04/15/2026

Fueled up and turning FOUR 🏁🔥 These Hot Wheels cookies are ready to race into the sweetest birthday yet!

04/06/2026

Snip snip! ✂️ Celebrating a permanent pause on diaper duty with something a little sweeter. 🍪

Address

Wauwatosa, WI

Website

facebook.com

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Firefly Cookie Co posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Firefly Cookie Co:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Interior Service in Wauwatosa?