Firefly Cookie Co

Contact the business

Firefly Cookie Co Perry Hicks
🍪 Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies
🎉 Birthdays • Showers • Weddings • Events
📍 Wauwatosa, WI | Milwaukee Area
💌 DM to order

A sweet way to celebrate a future doctor! 🩺🎓💙 These custom cookies were made for a Butler University student to celebrat...
10/02/2026

A sweet way to celebrate a future doctor! 🩺🎓💙 These custom cookies were made for a Butler University student to celebrate all the hard work and dedication that goes into becoming a doctor. Congratulations on this exciting accomplishment!

A little sweetness for a very special First Communion! 🤍✝️🍪✨Such a special way to celebrate an important day! ...
09/25/2026

A little sweetness for a very special First Communion! 🤍✝️🍪✨Such a special way to celebrate an important day!

🍪 Cookie Questions? I’ve got answers! ✨From ordering & pricing to pickup, here are some of my most asked questions! Have...
09/16/2026

🍪 Cookie Questions? I’ve got answers! ✨
From ordering & pricing to pickup, here are some of my most asked questions!

Have a question? Drop it below! ⬇️

Save this post for when you’re ready to order & share this post with someone who is planning an event!!

Sprinkling a little extra love for Baby Barribeau! 🎀💕 A sweet baby girl is on the way, and we’re celebrating with cookie...
09/11/2026

Sprinkling a little extra love for Baby Barribeau! 🎀💕 A sweet baby girl is on the way, and we’re celebrating with cookies as sweet as she is! 🌸🍼✨

A sweet send-off for coach Richard who will definitely be missed! These cookies were made for Badger CrossFit to celebra...
08/30/2026

A sweet send-off for coach Richard who will definitely be missed! These cookies were made for Badger CrossFit to celebrate his next chapter and wish him the very best on his move. 🏋️‍♂️🍪

From pushing us through tough WODs to always keeping us motivated, he’s made a lasting impact. We’ll definitely miss having him as our coach, but we’re cheering him on for this next adventure!

Back-to-school season is here! 📚✏️ Find these cookies at Look for Less. Celebrate with cookies made to make those first ...
08/21/2026

Back-to-school season is here! 📚✏️ Find these cookies at Look for Less.

Celebrate with cookies made to make those first days a little sweeter! 🍪💕

A sweet surprise for an even sweeter "YES!" 💍🍪✨Congratulations to Gio & Maddy on your engagement!
08/07/2026

A sweet surprise for an even sweeter "YES!" 💍🍪✨
Congratulations to Gio & Maddy on your engagement!

Finishing out the summer with a few more graduation cookies- Congratulations to class of 2026!!
07/29/2026

Finishing out the summer with a few more graduation cookies- Congratulations to class of 2026!!

A little berry is on the way! 🍓🫐 These "Someone Berry Sweet Is Coming" baby shower cookies were such a joy to create. Wi...
07/21/2026

A little berry is on the way! 🍓🫐 These "Someone Berry Sweet Is Coming" baby shower cookies were such a joy to create. Wishing the mama-to-be a shower filled with love, laughter, and the sweetest memories. 💕

Blooming with love and sweet anticipation. 🌸🤍 These delicate floral baby shower cookies were made to celebrate the sweet...
07/09/2026

Blooming with love and sweet anticipation. 🌸🤍 These delicate floral baby shower cookies were made to celebrate the sweetest little blossom on the way.

Address

Wauwatosa, WI

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Firefly Cookie Co posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Firefly Cookie Co:

Shortcuts

Share