The Witch’s Pantry

The Witch’s Pantry Small-batch sourdough, preserves & treats.

Formerly That’s My Jam!, now The Witch’s Pantry—where everything is handcrafted with patience, a pinch of magic, and a little bit of mischief. 🌙🖤

I don’t think I’ll ever get tired of this part. 🥹✨ Taking the lids off mid-bake and seeing that oven spring gets me ever...
09/08/2026

I don’t think I’ll ever get tired of this part. 🥹✨ Taking the lids off mid-bake and seeing that oven spring gets me every single time. Cordelia really does know what she’s doing. 🖤🍞

09/07/2026

There’s something so satisfying about turning a sticky little mess into a perfectly shaped loaf. 🍞🔮

09/03/2026

A little Strawberry Gin Sorcery in the making 🍓🔮

✨ A little Pantry reminder! ✨The Witch’s Pantry will NOT be taking orders next week while I take a little break from the...
09/02/2026

✨ A little Pantry reminder! ✨

The Witch’s Pantry will NOT be taking orders next week while I take a little break from the normal baking schedule to get everything ready for the Red Oak Fall Festival on September 12th! 🖤🍂

That means this week is your last chance to snag something before market week!

I also still have a few goodies ready to go right now 👀

🌀 3 Bewitched Buns — $5 each
🍂 Fall Bakery Bars — $5 each
✨ Plus, I’m still taking orders for the rest of this week!

After that, the kitchen officially goes into full market-prep mode 🧙🏻‍♀️🍞🍎

Thank y’all SO much for keeping me busy, I cannot wait to show you everything I’m bringing to Red Oak! 🖤

✨ BEWITCHED BUNS READY TO GO! ✨I have 4 individual Bewitched Buns up for grabs today! 🌀🖤🥐 $5 eachFresh, gooey, cinnamon-...
09/01/2026

✨ BEWITCHED BUNS READY TO GO! ✨

I have 4 individual Bewitched Buns up for grabs today! 🌀🖤

🥐 $5 each

Fresh, gooey, cinnamon-y goodness and first come, first served! 🔮

Comment or message me to claim yours before they disappear! ✨

Three little spells made for crisp mornings, cozy kitchens, and everything we love about fall. 🧙‍♀️🍁 Maplewood Magic — m...
08/31/2026

Three little spells made for crisp mornings, cozy kitchens, and everything we love about fall. 🧙‍♀️

🍁 Maplewood Magic — maple pecan topped with a buttery maple crumble
🎃 The Great Pumpkin Hex — spiced pumpkin loaded with white chocolate chips
🍎 C***r House Spell — apple pie topped with cinnamon sugar

All three are officially part of The Witch’s Pantry fall lineup and available to order now. 🖤

🍂The Pantry has officially entered its fall era. 🎃The fall menu is HERE and officially available for order! 🖤For anyone ...
08/29/2026

🍂The Pantry has officially entered its fall era. 🎃

The fall menu is HERE and officially available for order! 🖤

For anyone who doesn’t want to wait-I’ll have the first batch of fall Bakery Bars ready to go as soon as TOMORROW EVENING!

Everything else on the fall menu is available to order now — just send me a message to get yours on the books! 🖤

Now the only question is…

What are you trying FIRST?! 👀

08/29/2026

First attempt at an ube sourdough loaf and I don’t think I was prepared for THAT color when I cut into it. 😍
Safe to say Cordelia understood the assignment. ✨

Now the important question… would you try this one? 💜

This is usually what my kitchen counter looks like every night 😂🍞There’s almost always a bowl (or three) of dough hangin...
08/29/2026

This is usually what my kitchen counter looks like every night 😂🍞

There’s almost always a bowl (or three) of dough hanging out, Cordelia putting in overtime, and me testing something new for The Witch’s Pantry.

Tonight’s experiment? An ube sourdough loaf. 👀💜

Address

668 Struy St
Gibsonville, NC
27249

Telephone

+13362808191

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Witch’s Pantry posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Witch’s Pantry:

Shortcuts

Share