06/02/2026
Comet – Milwaukee, WI
Overall: A-
Compact Turkey Dinner - Thanksgiving dinner, all rolled into one! A mix of slow-roasted turkey, sage stuffing, & chive mashed potatoes that’s beer-battered, fried, & topped with country gravy. Served with Vegetable of the Day
Buffalo Chicken Sammie - Hand-breaded fried chicken, house pickles, chipotle mayo, lettuce, tomato, on a sesame seed bun. Served with fries & a pickle spear
Overview – Comet Café is a diner in Milwaukee’s east side. They have a medium-size space with a wrap-around bar – half standard bar and half low-top counter seating. Their menu includes a mix of breakfast food, sandwiches, a few entrees, sides, salads, apps, and pie all of which are elevated beyond conventional diner offerings.
Turkey Dinner – Turkey and stuffing were folded into mashed potato balls that were then battered and fried until crispy. They came drizzled with gravy and served with a side of green beans with almonds and cranberries. The balls were mashed potato forward with most of the flavor coming from the potatoes, chives, and the gravy, which combined nicely. Stuffing was pretty muted and the turkey was present mostly in texture with a mild flavor. The creamy-tender-crunchy texture combination was very nice. The beans were cooked simply and effectively. The almond added a nice textural contrast. The cranberried added acidity but I found them to be an ineffective flavor pairing.
Buffalo Chicken Sammie – The crispy chicken sandwich ordered buffalo style. Chicken sandwich was great – tender chicken with crispy breading, great buffalo character with moderate heat and tang. Pickle acidity, chipotle mayo added creamy richness, lettuce and tomato added vegetal balance, bun was tender. Fries were very crispy and tender inside, well salted.
Summary – Elevated yet non-pretentious comfort food. Comet integrates into Milwaukee in a way that makes it somewhat under the radar yet simultaneously a celebration of Midwest food.