The Fussy Pup

Home
United States
Seymour, IN
The Fussy Pup

Over 1200 Different Cookie Cutters, Dog Breeds, Christmas Cookie Cutters and More We started selling our cookie cutters online in the early 2000's. Creating.

A note from Kimberly:
... I'm pretty sure I thought Charles was nuts when he said he wanted to make dog cookie cutters .... We'd been dabbling in copper since about 1995. As a career for a short while then in our spare time when it was hard to find a market and a battle to afford our supplies. The days of making copper watering cans and baking pans were over and it was time to reinvent ourselves

. We did poorly at it. We weren't making enough to make ends meet and hadn't learned the fine art of customer service... something we strive for daily here at The Fussy Pup. So, we had to quit for a while... but in early 2013 we finally got the opportunity to try again and Charles was able to quit his job at the local retail giant and get back to what he loves! His imagination never stops, whether it's designing a new cookie cutter, working in the gardens, or creating something awesome in the wood shop. A couple years later in early 2015 I too was able to quit my day job and be here full time. About a year later we as we created and grew we were able to hire my sister full time too! It's busy, busy, busy here at The Fussy Pup as we're always expanding in one way or another. In 2018 we bought our new location in downtown Seymour Indiana. We now have 7 employees on our payroll and so many new projects at hand. It's a constant evolution of our ideas to keep us growing. Here at The Fussy Pup we do what we can to make sure that every one of our customers is satisfied. We are only human we make mistakes from time to time but we will do everything in our powers to correct it should it happen! We strive to ship daily and get orders out the following day of purchase. Any questions? Please message us. We'll get back with you as quickly as possible. ~ Thanks, Kimberly

01/06/2026

Cinnamon shortbread, fresh from the oven 🤍
Cutout-friendly and full of cozy flavor.

Recipe →
https://thefussypup.com/pages/cinnamon-shortbread-cutouts-recipe

01/05/2026

🦜 Happy National Bird Day! 🦜

Who’s ready to let their baking take flight? 🐦
Our Blue Jay Cookie Cutter is here to help you whip up some seriously tweet-worthy treats! Bold, beautiful, and handcrafted from copper, it’s perfect for bird lovers and creative bakers alike.

✨ Great for:
• Fun bird-shaped cookies
• Nature-inspired baking days
• Gifting to your favorite bird fan

Show us your feathered bakes! 📸

09/02/2025

⚡ Clearance Sale! ⚡
Cookie cutters $10 & under.
Limited stock — once they’re gone, they’re gone!

https://thefussypup.com/collections/clearance-cutters-limited-stock

08/20/2025

🎉 We’ve been busy in the workshop… and we brought treats. 🍪
Our handmade copper cookie cutters now start at $12.99 — and shipping is free at $35+.
Peek at the new homepage to browse Fall & Halloween shapes, shop by dog breed, and try our free dog games & printables—all crafted in Indiana.

👉 https://thefussypup.com/

Which fall shape should we bake first—🎃 pumpkin, 🦇 bat, or 🍁 maple leaf? 👇

03/29/2025

Dog Breed Love in Every Shirt 🐾
Our Hooded Long-Sleeve T-Shirts are lightweight, comfy, and full of canine character. Whether you're out with your pup or just love repping your favorite breed, these shirts are made to move with you—and make a statement.

🐕 Dozens of dog breed designs (and more coming!)
🎨 Original art you won’t find anywhere else
🖤 Soft, breathable fabric with a flattering fit
🎁 Perfect for gifts or everyday wear

🛍️ Shop the full collection → thefussypup.com/collections/hooded-long-sleeve-t-shirts

03/22/2025

🐉 A Sneak Peek Behind the Flying Dragon Cookie Cutter! 🐉

This bold design is handcrafted from copper and shaped using our custom hand-forged forming tool — made just for our cutters! 🔥 Every curve, every detail, shaped with care right here in Indiana.

Whether you bake with it, gift it, or display it, the Flying Dragon is made to impress.
✨ Unique design
🛠️ Hand-formed craftsmanship
🎁 One-of-a-kind gift for dragon lovers and cookie enthusiasts alike

Follow along for more behind-the-scenes magic from The Fussy Pup! 💚

03/17/2025

🐶 Cozy, Stylish, and Made for Dog Lovers! 🐶

Stay warm and show off your love for dogs with our hooded long-sleeve T-shirts! Perfect for everyday wear, these comfy and stylish designs are made just for you.

🖤 Soft & warm
🐾 Unique dog-inspired designs
🎁 Great gift for any dog lover

✨ Grab yours now! → https://thefussypup.com/collections/hooded-long-sleeve-t-shirts

📸 Tag us in your pics—we’d love to see you and your pup rocking your new hoodie!

03/15/2025

Excited to share the latest addition to my shop: Handmade Copper Cuff Bracelet, Twisted Wire Jewelry for Women, 6-7.5 Inches, Natural or Antiqued Finish https://etsy.me/3Dvb0T2 #

03/07/2025

Bake up a little luck! 🍀

Our Shamrock Delight Chocolate Mint Cookies are the perfect festive treat—sweet, minty, and as joyful as finding a four-leaf clover! 🌟

Pair them with our Lucky Shamrock Cookie Cutter for flawless results every time.

✨ Fun fact: Did you know the four-leaf clover represents hope, faith, love, and luck? Make your own lucky batch and add a little magic to your St. Patrick’s Day celebrations!

(P.S. Find the recipe and cutter on our website—they’re must-haves for festive baking fun!)

03/05/2025

Celebrate with a nod to Irish heritage and your love for dogs! 🍀🐾

Our handcrafted Irish Setter Cookie Cutter is perfect for creating festive bakes inspired by this enthusiastic and adventurous breed. ❤️

Whether it’s for St. Patrick’s Day or just because, honor this beautiful breed with treats that celebrate their spirit!

What’s your favorite Irish-inspired treat? Let us know in the comments! 🐾✨

03/03/2025

Math lovers and bakers unite! 🥧✨

Pi Day (3.14) is almost here, and that means one thing—deliciously clever treats! Whether you're baking up classic pies or getting creative with cookies, our Pi Cookie Cutter is a fun way to add a little math magic to your kitchen. 🍪🧮

What’s your go-to Pi Day treat—pie, cookies, or something even nerdier? Drop your answer below! ⬇️✨

(P.S. We’ve got the perfect cutter to help you prep for the big day! 😉)

02/28/2025

Feeling lucky? 🍀

St. Patrick’s Day is just around the corner, and it’s the perfect time to bake up some festive fun! Whether you’re making sweet treats for a party or celebrating with family, our handcrafted Lucky Shamrock Cookie Cutter brings the magic to your kitchen. ☘️💚

What’s your favorite St. Patrick’s Day tradition? Let us know in the comments! 🍀✨

(P.S. We’ve got some festive cutters perfect for the occasion! 😉)

Address

Seymour, IN

Telephone

+18122161140

Website

http://thefussypup.com/

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when The Fussy Pup posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to The Fussy Pup:

Shortcuts

Want your business to be the top-listed Interior Service in Seymour?